How to Compare Home Offers in San Diego: Look Beyond the Price

by Trevor Landress

To compare home offers, line up each one by what you would actually walk away with and how likely it is to close, not just by the headline price. A higher offer with a big credit, a long closing and a weak loan can be worth less than a lower offer that is clean and firm. This guide shows San Diego sellers how to build a side-by-side comparison, what each term means and which red flags to ask your agent about.

The short answer

Compare offers by estimated net proceeds and by how likely each is to close.
Credits, repair requests and closing costs can shrink a high price.
Contingencies, financing and the earnest money deposit show how firm an offer is.
Ask your agent for a simple chart that shows every offer on the same lines.

Start with your net, not the price

Two offers with different prices can leave you with similar money after costs and credits. That is why the first step is to estimate what you would net from each one. My guide on net proceeds from selling a home shows how to build that estimate.

Here is a labeled hypothetical. The numbers are made up to show the idea and are not a prediction.

Hypothetical term	Offer A	Offer B	Offer C
Offer price	$1,000,000	$985,000	$1,010,000
Credit to buyer	$15,000	$0	$40,000
Price after credit	$985,000	$985,000	$970,000
Loan contingency	17 days	Waived	30 days
Closing date	45 days	21 days	60 days
Earnest money deposit	$20,000	$40,000	$10,000

Offer C has the highest price and ends up the lowest after the credit. Offers A and B look the same after the credit, but Offer B closes in half the time, with a larger deposit and fewer conditions. Which one is better depends on your plans, and that is the point of lining them up.

The terms that change the deal

Financing and down payment

Cash offers and offers with large down payments tend to have fewer financing surprises. Ask for a pre-approval letter or proof of funds, and ask your agent how firm the lender is. If a buyer is borrowing close to the top of the local loan limit, the loan may have extra steps. The Federal Housing Finance Agency posts the limit for each county every year.

Contingencies

A contingency is a condition that lets the buyer cancel without losing their deposit if it is not met. Common ones cover the inspection, the appraisal and the loan. Shorter or fewer contingencies mean less risk for you, but waiving them is the buyer's choice. My buyer-side guide on home buying contingencies explains each type.

Appraisal terms

If the home appraises below the price, someone has to cover the gap or the deal changes. Some buyers promise to cover a set amount. Others do not. I walk through this in what a low appraisal means for sellers.

Deposit, closing date and possession

A larger earnest money deposit shows the buyer has more to lose if they walk away. The closing date should match your move plan, and some buyers will allow you to stay for a few days after closing in a rent-back. If you also need to buy another home, tell your agent early so the dates can line up.

Red flags to ask about

A very high price paired with a large credit or a very long inspection period.
A pre-approval letter that is old, vague or from an unknown lender.
A deposit that is very small for the price of the home.
Terms that ask you to pay for many repairs or to fix problems before closing.
A buyer who needs to sell another home first and has not yet listed it.

None of these means an offer is bad. They are reasons to ask questions before you sign. If you are getting several offers at once, my guide on handling multiple offers covers the process.

How to build your own comparison chart

List each offer in a column and use the same rows for all of them.
Add price, credits, down payment, loan type and deposit.
Add contingencies and how many days each one lasts.
Add the closing date and any rent-back request.
Ask your agent for your estimated net on every offer, after commissions, fees and credits.
Mark each offer as low, medium or high risk of not closing, and write one sentence for why.

A note on disclosures and timing

Whichever buyer you choose, they should receive your disclosure packet before the contract is final, or they may have a right to cancel. I explain the timing in my seller disclosures guide below. Strong paperwork also makes offers cleaner.

This is not a guarantee

No chart can promise that a deal will close. Buyers can cancel for reasons that nobody can predict, and numbers like credits and costs change with each negotiation. Use your comparison as a tool and talk through the details with your agent before you decide.

My advice for San Diego sellers

Compare offers by your estimated net and the odds of closing, not just by price.
Ask for proof of funds or a pre-approval letter and call the lender if something looks thin.
Read every contingency and note how long each one lasts.
Match the closing date and possession to your move plan.
Ask your agent to put all offers in one clear chart before you decide.

Call or text me at (619) 402-4614 or send me a message.

Call or text (619) 402-4614 Contact Trevor Landress

Related guides

Frequently asked questions

How do I compare home offers?

Put every offer in one chart and compare price, credits, financing, contingencies, deposit and closing date. Then estimate what you would net from each and how likely it is to close.

Is the highest offer always the best?

No. A high price can come with large credits, long contingencies or weak financing. A lower offer with firm terms can leave you with the same money and less risk.

Is a cash offer better than a financed offer?

A cash offer removes loan risk, so it can be safer and faster. A financed offer with a strong pre-approval and a high deposit can also be a good choice.

What is a contingency in an offer?

It is a condition that lets the buyer cancel without losing their deposit if it is not met, such as an inspection, appraisal or loan condition.

What should I ask for before I accept an offer?

Ask for a pre-approval letter or proof of funds, the deposit amount, the length of each contingency, any credit request and your estimated net proceeds.

About the author

Trevor Landress is a San Diego REALTOR® with Coldwell Banker West (DRE# 02126901). He was born and raised in San Diego and has been licensed since 2021.

Trevor is part of the Campbell Group, a three-generation real estate team, and he and the Campbell Group consistently rank as a top producing team at Coldwell Banker West each month.

He helps homeowners sell, guides first-time buyers through the home buying process and assists investors with their next acquisition. His work includes negotiating offers, analyzing market trends, building pricing strategies and running marketing campaigns for his listings. He serves clients across San Diego County, from coastal communities like La Jolla, Del Mar and Carlsbad to neighborhoods inland.

He writes these guides to help San Diego buyers and sellers navigate an ever-changing market. To talk through your plans, call or text (619) 402-4614 or contact Trevor Landress.

How I help San Diego home buyers

I walk buyers through each step, from getting pre-approved and touring homes to writing offers, reviewing inspections and getting to the closing table. I explain the numbers in plain English so you know what you are agreeing to before you sign.

How I help San Diego home sellers

I help sellers price their home from recent sold comparables, plan prep and photos, review every offer beyond the price, and keep the sale on track through inspection, appraisal and closing.